IU School of Optometry Continuing Education
Differential Diagnosis and Management of Viral Keratoconjunctivitis

Part 2: Problem Solving with Herpes Simplex Keratitis

IU Optometry continuing education main page
continuing education seminars and workshops
online continuing education
paraoptometric certification program information

IU Optometry home page
about the school
admissions information
clinics & patient care information
optometry library information
news and events
people
programs
research
information for students

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) is the leading cause of infectious corneal blindness in the United States with 500,000 cases reported annually (50,000 new & recurrent cases each year). By adult life, 97 percent of the population has herpes simplex antibodies. It may occur in any age group, but primary infection peak ages are first and second decades. Approximately 20-25 percent of epithelial HSV infections can lead to stromal involvement with scarring.


Go to: Viral Keratoconjunctivitis CE table of contents


URL: http://www.opt.indiana.edu/ce/virker/part2.htm
Revised: November 28, 2005
IU Optometry home page: http://www.opt.indiana.edu/
Comments (content): Dr. Vic Malinovsky at malinovs@indiana.edu or Dr. Jane Ann Grogg at jgrogg@indiana.edu
Comments: Web Administrator
Page design and coding: Terri Greene
Copyright © 2005, The Trustees of Indiana University


About Herpes Simplex Virus (HSV)

Herpes simplex virus (Type 1 and 2) is an obligate, intracellular parasite commonly the cause of fever blisters, cold sores, genital labialis, and ocular diseases. Herpes simplex virus can manifest itself in a number of ocular presentations.

  • Vesicular and ulcerative lid lesions: blepharitis
  • Conjunctivitis
  • Corneal disease: keratitis (epithelial and stromal) and corneal scarring
  • Glaucoma
  • Uveitis
  • Retinitis

HSV Type 1 infections involve the eyes, nose, mouth, and lips; whereas, HSV Type 2 infections involve the genital region. Type 2 infections can be transmitted sexually as well as neonatally (infected birth canal). Type 2 infections rarely involve the eye, although HSV Type 2 corneal disease tends to be worse than Type 1.

Type 1 and Type 2 may infect opposite areas with an undistinguishable clinical appearance (usually safe to say not venereal). Primary infection is the first infection in person who lacks antibodies to the virus. The virus travels up the neuronal structures to trigeminal ganglion for HSV-1 and spinal for HSV-2. Latency state of virus occurs 2-3 weeks after primary infection in trigeminal or spinal ganglion. There is some evidence for corneal latency.

Recurrences are usually at the site of initial involvement, but may be in the eye. Stress factors may cause recurrent attacks with virus multiplying and traveling down the neuronal pathway to ocular areas.

Stress factors include:

  • Wind, sunlight, or ultraviolet exposure
  • Fever
  • Menstruation or pregnancy
  • Emotional or physiological stress
  • Topical steroids
  • Ocular injury
  • Lack of sleep

[Return to top]


Clinical Presentation

May occur as a component of primary or recurrent infection with/without eyelid vesicles and with/without keratitis. Unilateral in more than 80 percent of cases.

Primary Blepharokeratoconjunctivitis

Found more often in children and young adults (than in adults). It may initially look like any other viral conjunctivitis. Primary blepharokeratoconjunctivitis usually resolves in 10-14 days (self-limiting).

Symptoms

  • Systemic complaints of malaise, fever, achiness, URI, and oral lesions
  • Ocular complaints of redness, watery or mucoid discharge, itching, irritation, photophobia, and lid swelling

Signs

  • Ipsilateral preauricular lymph node enlarged and/or tender
  • Lid lesions with a conjunctivitis
    • Found on eyelids or lid margins; variable eyelid swelling and tenderness
    • Often hidden by eyelashes
    • Lesions on face or mouth
    • Vesicles or ulcers
    • Vesicles with erythematous base; later become pustular, crust, ulcerate, and heal without scarring; may involve lid, lid margin, or eyelashes
    • Lid margin ulcer/erosions will stain with NaFl and Rose Bengal
    • Eyelid lesions may resemble Staph, Herpes zoster, chicken pox, or vaccinia lesions

Conjunctivitis

Signs

  • Follicular of lower palpebral conjunctiva
  • Upper palpebral conjunctiva shows a papillary response
  • Bulbar conjunctiva hyperemia, edema, and some rare cases ulcerations (conjunctival dendrite)
  • Rare pseudomembranes with secondary fine linear scars remaining
  • Skin or lid vesicle may be present or absent

Corneal Lesions

Keratitis accompanies the conjunctivitis in one third to one half of cases. It usually occurs 7-14 days after onset of skin lesions. Overall duration of primary infection is usually 2-3 weeks. The length of time decreases to 11 days with treatment.

Signs

  • Diffuse or limbal punctate epithelial keratitis
  • Rarely microdendrites or small dendritic ulcers
  • Lesions are usually small and transitory, often lasting 1-3 days
  • Rarely stromal disciform keratitis

Click image for larger view.
infected eye HSK: vasicular skin lesions
infected eye HSK: ulcerative blepharokeratoconjunctivitis
infected eye HSK: lid lesions and conjunctivitis
infected eye HSK: preceptal cellulitis secondary to Herpes skin lesion
infected eye HSK: resolving 5 days later
infected eye HSK: resolved lesion 2 weeks later
infected eye HSK: lid margin ulceration with NaFl (sodium fluorescein) staining
infected eye HSK: punctate keratitis--early microdendrite
infected eye HSK: punctate/microdendrite keratitis
infected eye HSK: multiple microdendrites

[Return to top]


Recurrent Infections

Recurrent infections may occur at any age. 20-25 percent of patients with primary infection will have a recurrence. Half of patients with recurrent infection will have another attack in 2 years.

Symptoms

  • May be asymptomatic
  • Redness
  • Itching
  • Irritation
  • Blurred vision
  • Tearing
  • Photophobia
  • Foreign body sensation
  • Rarely pain

Signs

  • Corneal lesions more common than the lid and conjunctival lesions
    Types of corneal lesions:
    • Epithelial keratitis (dendritic or amoeboid)
    • Stromal keratitis (disciform and necrotizing)
  • Rarely lid margin ulcerations
  • Rarely follicular conjunctivitis; mild conjunctival hyperemia or ciliary injection (eye often not very red)

Epithelial lesions: active viral replication

  • Coarse punctate epithelial keratitis
  • Stellate or microdendrites coalescing in a few days into dendritic ulcers--linear, fine, lacy, branching lesion with terminal end bulbs
  • Geographic/amoebic ulcers (progressive enlargement of ulcer); often topical steroid-induced
  • Single or multiple
  • Swollen epithelial cells at the edges stain with rose bengal/lissamine green, and necrotic cells in base/center stain with NaFl
  • Central or limbal lesions (more resistant to treatment; may resemble marginal keratitis)
  • Sterile trophic or metaherpetic
  • Decreased corneal sensitivity; cotton wisp test, initially localized; with more recurrences, more generalized anesthesia
  • Occasionally associated with mild subepithelial infiltrates and mild stromal edema appearing under the ulcer; often resolves once epithelium heals
  • Following healing, the epithelium may manifest "pseudodendrites"--don't mistake for active infection
  • Mild corneal scarring; nebular/ghost scars--especially after attacks
  • Patients with AIDS are more likely to have marginal dendrite, longer to heal

Laboratory evaluations rarely performed

  • Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is simple, rapid, and reliable diagnostic test even if treatment has been started. SureCellª (Kodak) and MicroTrak¨ (Syva).
  • Viral cultures

Click image for larger view.
infected eye HSK: recurrent lid margin ulceration with NaFl staining
infected eye HSK: severe ulcerative blepharokeratoconjunctivitis; previously treated with topical steroid (wrong med)
infected eye HSK: (same patient as directly above) limbal dendrites and early peripheral corneal dendrite
infected eye HSK: dendritic corneal ulcer
infected eye HSK: dendritic corneal ulcer
infected eye HSK: dendritic corneal ulcer
infected eye HSK: limbal dendrite
infected eye HSK: early geographic ulcer
infected eye HSK: large dendritic ulcer

[Return to top]


Differential Diagnosis

  • Herpes zoster ophthalmicus (HZO) keratitis
  • Healing corneal abrasion
  • Contact lens wear
  • Acanthamoeba keratitis
  • Toxic keratitis

[Return to top]


Treatment and Management

Treatment of HSK is primarily based on whether the corneal condition is caused solely by active virus, as in dendritic keratitis, or has an immune response component, as in disciform keratitis.

Management of Dendritic Keratitis

Goals

  • Preserving vision
  • Preventing recurrent attacks
  • Aggressive and early treatment to reduce the possibility of stromal disease and scarring

Treatment

  • Decide whether active virus is present with rose bengal or lissamine green dye; if uncertain, re-evaluate in 24 hours
  • Self-limited (if untreated) in 50% in 1 to 2 weeks
  • Initial treatment with topical antivirals; rarely mechanical debridement

    Topical Antiviral Solutions

    Viroptic 1% ophthalmic solution q2h x 2 days 9 times daily, then q3-4h until the lesion resolves completely, then have patient continue the medication qid/tid for another week to ensure suppression of the virus. (Others say full dose by 14-21 days, continue therapy after healing, may taper for 2-3 weeks.) 97% of cases resolve within 2 weeks.

    Viroptic Solution (1%Trifluridine)
    • Monarch Pharmaceuticals
    • Preservative: Thimerosal
    • 7.5 ml retail cost approximately $100 (2005)
    • Stored under refrigeration
    • Generic available; still expensive
    • Approved for use in patients 6 yrs & older
    • Interfers with DNA synthesis

    Also effective is Acyclovir 3% ointment 5 times per day as well as new ganciclovir 0.15% gel--although neither are yet available in the United States.

    Possible adverse reactions from topical antivirals

    • Hypersensitivity reactions--contact dermatitis
    • Punctate epithelial keratopathy--filamentary keratitis
    • Follicular conjunctivitis
    • Punctal stenosis
    • Avoid use in treating pregnant and nursing women unless benefits outweigh the potential risks

    Trifluridine is the drug of choice in US, but use an alternative antiviral drug if adverse reactions occur. The normal response to treatment is dramatic with breaking up of an ulcer into smaller islands ("Morse Code" healing). If no response in 7 days--then consider compliance, resistance, proper diagnosis, and different antiviral. The routine use of topical antibiotics is not necessary; they may enhance corneal toxicity. May need to prescribe 5% homatropine bid.

  • Debridement

    While debridement was the choice of treatment in the past, most recent studies show that debridement may not be as effective as antiviral therapy. It may, however, be used in conjunction with antivirals. Use a cotton swab or spatula with topical anesthetic (caution if lesion central; more scarring?); return in 24 hours.

Herpes Simplex Blepharoconjuntivitis

  • Lid lesions without corneal involvement
  • Viroptic drops qid until lid lesion resolves
  • Oral acyclovir 400 mg 5x/day x 7 days?

Neurotrophic Keratitis/Indolent Ulcers

Result of . . .

  • Basement membrane damaged from previous keratitis
  • Anesthetic cornea
  • Abnormal tear film

No active viral replication; sterile erosion of the epithelium.

Appearance: round, oval epithelial defect with rolled edges, mild uveitis. May lead to stromal thinning and perforation.

Trophic/neurotrophic ulcer is difficult to treat. Discontinue antivirals and treat with:

  • Instill antibiotic ointment (e.g., Polysporin/Erythromycin 2-4 times daily plus cycloplegic agent bid)
  • May try pressure patching or bandage lens
  • Mild topical steroids?
  • Tarsorrhapaphy
  • Monitor closely for secondary infection (may need cultures) and progression to perforation
  • Refer to corneal subspecialist if not healing

Topical steroids are contraindicated in epithelial active virus disease. Enhanced viral replication and prolongation of disease may result in deeper lesions, and disciform keratitis is more likely. Secondary bacterial and fungal infections may occur. Increased IOP and formation of cataracts are possible.

Disciform Keratitis

  • Antigen/antibody response, delayed cell mediated hypersensitivity
  • 10-20 percent of those with epithelial dendrites will have concurrent or delayed stromal disciform keratitis.
  • 5-10 days after dendrite or several months or years later, even with no history of infection
  • Photophobia, pain, red eye, and reduced VA
  • Appearance of stromal edema in a disc-shaped area, cell infiltrate, folds in Descemet's, epithelium intact, microcystic edema, KPs, pseudoguttata, AC reaction, elevated IOPs (trabeculitis), often results in stromal scarring

Treatment of disciform keratitis includes a cycloplegic, topical steroids, B-blockers for elevated IOP, and antiviral coverage. If very mild and off the visual axis, use cycloplegics (e.g., 5% homatropine 3 times daily and lubricating drops for comfort) to control uveitis. If affecting the vision because of its severity or location, then use topical steroids (1% Prednisolone acetate [Pred Forte] or Lotemax qid), trying to use the lowest dose possible--refer to HEDS (Herpetic Eye Disease Study). Topical antivirals (1% Viroptic solution) should be administered concurrently any time steroids are used. Usually 4 times daily is adequate prophylaxis.

Tapering of Medications: Disciform keratitis usually responds quickly to steroids, but the patient's Pred Forte must be tapered very slowly. Continue taper with Pred Mild or Alrex. Patient may be on these drops for several months or years. Once the steroid is only once daily, you can discontinue the antiviral agents.

Disciform keratitis may leave a scar. If scarring is visually significant, may need PKP (penetrating keratoplasty). Recurrences in graft are common.

Necrotizing Stromal Keratitis

  • Live virus in stroma
  • Appearance of stromal abscess with necrotizing, cheesy, white infiltrate in all layers of the cornea, stromal edema, vascularization , WessleyÕs immune rings, uveitis, hypopyon, iris rubeosis
  • Can lead to scarring, thinning, perforation

Treatment of necrotising stromal keratitis is similar to treatment of disciform keratitis (includes a cycloplegic, antivirals, topical steroids); however, a poorer response is typical. Rule out other infections (culture?). Refer to corneal subspecialist.

Click image for larger view.
First 5 photos are from same patient.
infected eye Neurotrophic ulcer
infected eye Neurotrophic keratitis
infected eye Neurotrophic keratitis with NaFl staining
infected eye Resolving neurotrophic keratitis
infected eye Corneal scarring
infected eye Small disciform stromal keratitis secondary to HSK
infected eye Large disciform stromal keratitis
infected eye Disciform stromal keratitis with keratic precipitants (KPs)

Herpetic Eye Disease Study

The Herpetic Eye Disease Study (HEDS) was originally undertaken to evaluate the usefulness of oral acyclovir in stromal HSV disease. It became much more as it progressed from September 1992 to December 1996. Over 700 patients with various manifestations of ocular HSV infection were examined. Many subgroups were studied.

HEDS Findings

  • Stromal disease can occur in the absence of previous epithelial lesions.
  • 400mg of oral acyclovir (Famvir not studied) twice per day for one year resulted in a 45% decrease in the rate of recurrence for all forms of ocular complications.
  • Over the six months after discontinuation, there was no rebound increase but no continued benefit.
  • Interestingly, the benefit mostly applied to those with previous stromal disease, not previous dendrites alone!.
  • Oral acyclovir did not improve outcomes in cases of stromal keratitis, with the possible exception of necrotizing disease (small sample).
  • Steroids are very effective in managing stromal infections and do not increase the rate of recurrence.
  • Oral acyclovir may benefit HSV iridocyclitis (small sample size).
  • Treatment of patients with epithelial dendrites with oral acyclovir does not reduce the rate of stromal disease or iritis.

Prophylactic Systemic Therapy

  • Oral acyclovir 400mg bid for 1 year or longer reduces the rate of recurrent epithelial and stromal keratitis by about 45%.
  • Effect disappears when drug is stopped.
  • Consider if 2 or more attacks of dendritic within a year or recurrent disciform keratitis.

NEI--HERPETIC EYE DISEASE STUDY Group
Acyclovir for the prevention of recurrent herpes simplex virus eye disease
N Engl J Med 1998 Jul 30;339(5): 300-6.

Herpetic Eye Disease Study--Acyclovir Prevention Trial

  • Recurrence rate of any form of ocular herpes was significantly lower in the acyclovir group (19%) than placebo group (32%). Represents a reduction by 41%.
  • Rate of recurrence of stromal keratitis from 28% to 14% (50% reduction)
  • Oral acyclovir 400mg bid x 1 year?

Oral Anti-Virals

  • Acyclovir (Zovirax)
    HZ: 800mg 5x/day x 7 days
    HS: 400mg 5x/day x 7 days
  • Valacyclovir (Valtrex)
    HZ: two 500mg tabs tid x 7 days
    HS: 500mg tabs tid x 7 days
  • Famciclovir (Famvir)
    HZ: 500mg tid x 7 days
    HS: 500mg bid x 7 days

Examples of When to Use Oral Antivirals

  • Patients with an allergy to topical Viroptic
  • Patients with primary HSV blepharodermatitis with/ without concurrent HSV keratitis
  • Patient with stromal keratitis when topical steroids are needed & patient had toxic reaction to Viroptic

[Return to top]


Go to: Viral Keratoconjunctivitis CE table of contents